The False Princess: Mary Carleton’s Deadly Masquerade

“You told me you were a lord, and I told you I was a princess—I think I fitted you.” The courtroom gasped at Mary Carleton’s audacious retort. There she stood, a supposed German noblewoman, effortlessly turning her accuser’s charge back on him with a mocking smile. It was 1663 in London, and Mary was on trial for bigamy and fraud. By rights she should have been trembling; instead, she played the part of an aggrieved princess so convincingly that the judges themselves were enchanted. How had a common girl from Canterbury bewitched the elite of England? The answer lies in Mary’s extraordinary talent for reinvention—and a fearless heart as cold as the gallows awaiting her.

Early Life and Formative Traits

Mary Carleton was not born to silk and privilege. In truth, she entered the world in 1642 as Mary Moders, daughter of a humble Canterbury fiddler. From a young age Mary chafed at the confines of poverty, dreaming of finer things. Clever and pretty, she learned how to wrap men around her finger with a batting eyelash and a sharp tongue. Her formative years were a tempest of misbehavior: a teenage marriage to a shoemaker named Stedman, two babies lost in infancy, and a restless spirit that refused to be tied down. Mary fled that dull life and soon committed her first bold deceit—marrying another man while her first husband still lived. Caught and tried for bigamy, the undaunted young woman wiggled free on a technicality. That brush with the law only emboldened her. Mary had tasted the power of a well-spun story and realized she possessed a rare gift: in a world that gave women few choices, she could create her own fate by telling whatever tale people most wanted to hear.

Psychological Drivers and Manipulation Style

What drove Mary was not just greed for money—though she loved jewels and coins, certainly. Deeper was her hunger for significance and revenge against a society that had overlooked and underestimated her. She discovered that pretending to be above her station made influential people finally take notice of her. With each lie, Mary felt a thrill of domination. Her manipulation style was rooted in keen social insight. She understood the vanity of wealthy men who swooned over titles and exotic backstories. So she gave them what they craved: the illusion of a blue-blooded beauty in distress. Mary was a superb actress with a darkly adaptive psyche—able to cry on cue about fictitious dead relatives, then coolly pocket the sympathy gifts pressed into her hands. She cloaked herself in refinement: perfect curtsies, fluent French phrases, a demure downcast gaze that hid a predator’s gleam. She weaponized the very stereotypes of female fragility, turning chivalrous impulses into her meal ticket. And underneath the silks and smiles was a heart that seemed to know no fear or remorse. Mary Carleton treated life as a grand masquerade ball; if she played her role impeccably, no one peered behind her mask until it was too late.

Major Impersonation Crimes and Schemes

Mary’s most infamous role was that of Princess van Wolway of Cologne—a fictional German noblewoman she conjured out of thin air. In 1663, she swept into Restoration London spinning a tragic yarn: war had killed her aristocratic family, a wicked suitor had driven her to flee her homeland, and now this gentle, cultured princess was alone in a foreign land. London’s high society ate it up. Mary donned elegant gowns and a modest veil of sorrow, carrying forged letters from distinguished “relatives” abroad to authenticate her persona. The ruse worked brilliantly. Smitten admirers plied her with expensive gifts and endless flattery. Before long, a well-to-do suitor—John Carleton, a lawyer’s son who fancied himself a nobleman—fell for the mysterious princess. Mary married him in a splendid ceremony, likely suppressing a grin behind her bridal veil. Here she was, a poor fiddler’s daughter, now wedded to an upper-class fool under an assumed name, living in luxury. But the fairytale began to fray: suspicions arose when no dowry or royal kin materialized. An anonymous letter exposed Mary’s lie, and she was arrested.

What followed was a theatrical trial that captivated the city. Mary, ever the performer, played her greatest part on the witness stand. She claimed she was the victim—John Carleton had misrepresented himself as a wealthy lord to ensnare her, only to turn on her when he realized she wasn’t rich. With feigned outrage and cutting wit, Mary delivered the famous line that left the court roaring: “You told me you were a lord, and I told you I was a princess—I think I fitted you.” The sheer cheek and cleverness of that statement won over the jury. How could they punish this quick-witted woman who made London’s elite look like fools? She walked free, acquitted against all odds. And Mary Carleton’s legend was born.

In the years after, Mary grew bolder and even more creative. She penned a bestselling pamphlet about her own adventures, shamelessly mythologizing herself. She even took to the stage, acting in a play about “the German Princess” to delighted crowds—imagine the brazen thrill of portraying her own lies as entertainment. Admirers flocked to her, and Mary welcomed them like a queen holding court. One smitten gentleman showered her with treasures and a marriage proposal; Mary accepted, then vanished with his money and jewels the moment his guard was down. She next masqueraded as a rich heiress on the run from an arranged marriage, complete with accomplices sending fake letters about her fictional estates. A kindly landlady introduced Mary to her nephew as a perfect match, unaware she was feeding a wolf into the fold. Mary staged an elaborate con: letters “from her brother” arrived with tales of inheritance and evil suitors. Hook, line, and sinker—the suitor invited Mary to stay with him for safety. That very night, Mary and a confederate, disguised as her maid, cleaned out the house of cash and valuables and melted away into the darkness. Over the next decade, countless men would find themselves similarly duped and discarded. Many were too embarrassed to admit they’d been fooled by a woman, which only helped Mary escape consequences. Each successful scam was a delicious morsel of victory for her. She had made the grand society her playground, and no one seemed able to stop her.

Downfall and Final Act

But even the most well-crafted masquerade cannot last forever. Mary’s final act began as her luck started to run dry. By the early 1670s, the authorities—and plenty of vengeful victims—were no longer amused by the German Princess’s antics. Mary was arrested yet again, this time for a relatively petty theft (she had stolen a silver plate from a household). But there was a bigger problem: in the course of her escapades, Mary had once been sentenced to penal transportation overseas for theft, a punishment she promptly evaded by sneaking back to England. Returning from exile was itself a capital offense. The net was closing, and Mary knew it. Still, she met her fate with defiant pride. In 1673, at roughly thirty years old, Mary Carleton was dragged to Tyburn gallows to answer for a lifetime of lies. Witnesses say she maintained a regal composure to the bitter end, dressing in her finery as if going to a royal engagement rather than her own execution. Perhaps in her mind, dying under the title of the “German Princess” was better than living again as plain Mary Moders. The rope was fitted around her neck as a crowd jeered and cheered—after years of duping men into matrimony, the princess’s play was over. In a moment, the floor fell away and so ended the life of one of England’s most notorious impostors. But even as her body went limp, her legend kicked and writhed its way into history.

A Chilling Takeaway

Mary Carleton’s story is both a dark cautionary tale and a perversely empowering saga of a woman who refused to accept the hand she was dealt. With nothing but her wits and audacity, she remade herself into an aristocrat and made fools of the rich and gullible. It’s easy to marvel at her confidence—how many of us could lie so boldly and walk so elegantly on the edge of a razor? Yet beneath Mary’s charm lay a cold opportunism; she treated hearts and trust as disposable playthings. In her rise and fall we see the timeless dance between deceiver and deceived. Mary’s victims believed her fantasies because they, too, were hungry—for love, status, or excitement. Her success exposes an unnerving truth: people will overlook obvious lies when those lies promise to fulfill their desires. And Mary, wickedly clever, knew it. The German Princess may have been a phantom, but she held up a mirror to society’s vanity and greed—and paid for it with her life. The next time a tale seems too perfect, remember the woman who wove whole identities out of thin air. The sharpest con artists wear disarming smiles and speak of dreams—until those dreams twist into nightmares. 

Stay curious, stay aware…  and continue reading our next impostor, The Impostor of a Thousand Faces: Ferdinand Demara’s Bold Deceptions

With thrills,

Penelope McGrath

About Penelope McGrath:

 Penelope McGrath is a psychological thriller author living in Puerto Rico with her two toddlers. She writes dark mysteries, twisted suspense, and curates eerie ambiance videos inspired by the island.

🔗 Download a free short story and Subscribe to her newsletter to uncover your next obsession.